MODERN SOURCES OF LEGAL ORATORY
Keywords:legal argumentation, informal argumentation, legal reasoning, practical argumentation
AbstractThis article is intended to spark the interest of legal practitioners for the development of argumentation skills. The link between rhetoric and law is analysed from the perspectives provided by The New Rhetoric: A Treatise on Argumentation by Chaïm Perelman and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca and The Uses of Argument by Stephen Toulmin, authors who contributed to the rebirth of informal argumentation in modern times. Perelman tries to explain how arguments work and draws from his vast legal knowledge to provide suitable examples for his theories regarding practical argumentation. Toulmin decides that formal argumentation does not fully explain the way in which people reason. He therefore develops his own system for analysing argumentation and also uses the legal field as a means of illustrating his ideas. The article at first analyses the particularity of each approach and then continues to point out some similarities between the two theories while also offering some perspectives for further study of legal oratory.
Cazacu Aurel M. (2007). Teoria argumentării, Editura România Press, București.
Foss Sonja K., Foss Karen A., Trapp Robert (1985). Contemporary Perspectives on Rhetoric, Waveland Press, Prospect Heights, IL.
Golden Robert, Berquist Goodwin F., Coleman William E., Golden Ruth and Sproule Michael J. (2007). The rhetoric of Western thought: From the Mediterranean world to the global setting, 9th ed., Dubuque.
Grimes William (2009). Stephen Toulmin, a Philosopher and Educator, Dies at 87, New York Times, December 11th.
Grosse Jack W. (1985). Chaim Perelman And The New Rhetoric. Northern Kentucky Law Review, 12.
Ionescu S. (2010). Principiile procedurii judiciare în reglementarea actuală şi în noile coduri de procedură, Ed. Universul Juridic, Bucureşti.
MacCormick Neil (1978). Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory, Oxford University Press.
Perelman Chaïm, Olbrechts-Tyteca Lucie (2012). Tratat de argumentare. Noua reto-rică, Editura Universității „Alexandru Ioan Cuza”, Iași.
Rawls John (1971). A Theory of Justice, Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge Massachusetts.
Scallen Eileen A. (1995). Classical Rhetoric, Practical Reasoning, and the Law of Evidence, American University Law Review, 44.
Smith Craig R. (2013). Rhetoric and Human Conciousness: A History, Fourth Edition, Waveland Press, Long Grove IL.
Toulmin St. (2003). The Uses of Argument, Updated Edition, Cambridge University Press, New York.